Every Puzzle ProjectJudge
Judge · No. 371 · December 1, 1936

Dirty Work at the Crosswords

by Karl R. Young
Submitted by Karl R. Young, San Francisco, Calif.

Printed without a number, as 'Dirty Work at the Crosswords'. Numbered 371 here by inference (the user, from the scans): the series runs from No. 370, earlier in this issue, to No. 372 in January 1937, and January 1937 printed this puzzle's solution beside No. 370's. The grid has circled squares; they aren't marked in this transcription yet.

As printed

The puzzle as printed in Judge, December 1, 1936
The puzzle as printed in Judge, December 1, 1936 · this page at the Internet Archive
The printed answer key
The answer key, printed in a later issue · that page at the Internet Archive

As transcribed

The grid and clues exactly as printed, misprints and all. Point at a clue to see where it was read on the page. • the OCR misread it and a reviewer fixed the reading (point at the dot for what it read); sic a misprint, kept as printed.

Across

  1. 1Nature of the crime.MURDER
  2. 6Victim's occupation. (clue).SALESMAN
  3. 14The No. 1 vertical got her job through an .... (abbr.).AD•
  4. 15In this mystery, you are .... ....THEDETECTIVE•
  5. 18The only doctor available.VET
  6. 19Every Clue.EC
  7. 20The .... said there were three stab wounds. (clue).DOC•
  8. 21The victim wore a .... suit, with one pair of pants.NEW•
  9. 23Whoever did it may have suffered from a mental ....QUIRK•
  10. 25Robbery Advanced (as motive).RA
  11. 27Police Officers (baffled, as is traditional).PO
  12. 28If you .... the clues properly; you'll get the solution, maybe.UNITE•
  13. 29The victim was noted for his manly ....COURAGE•
  14. 32There was a bottle with a big .... gone from it.SWIG•
  15. 33He had been having .... di ho, but not with H2O.HI
  16. 34.... you still on the job?ARE•
  17. 35.... liked to tell naughty stories.HE•
  18. 36The victim was a gay ....DOG•
  19. 39No. 1 vertical had a good ....ALIBI•
  20. 41But she said the victim was bad, in fact quite a .... (Some poetry, eh?)CAD•
  21. 42He had no .... enemies.KNOWN•
  22. 44Reject Suicide Motive.RSM
  23. 45Late Yesterday (a young woman) cont. below.LY
  24. 47Entered Apartment. (still cont.)EA
  25. 49Name Unknown (cherchez la femme).NU
  26. 50.... .... found on floor.SAWDUST•
  27. 53The culprit had had to .... in a hurry.SCRAM•
  28. 57This isn't becoming too ...., is it?EZ•
  29. 58The constable did his ....BEST•
  30. 59But .... was none too good.IT•
  31. 60This particle had nothing to do with the murder.ION•
  32. 61The constable was always good for a ....LAF
  33. 63The culprit had attended the State .... college. (clue).AG•
  34. 66A clue! The murderer's name is ....!LOU•
  35. 67The victim worked for a red paint ....MANUFACTURER•
  36. 73He No. 74 horizontal on the .... (clue).RR•
  37. 74See above.TRAVELED
  38. 75The maid gave a .... when she found the body.SHRIEK•

Down

  1. 1The crime was discovered by the ....MAID•
  2. 2Utterly Dumfounded (was she).UD•
  3. 3Distressingly Tearful (to see).DT
  4. 4Exceedingly Handsome (had been he).EH•
  5. 5.... decided upon as motive.REVENGE•
  6. 6Now we're all ....,SET•
  7. 7.... last, you bet;AT•
  8. 8....'s go and getLET•
  9. 9Every Clue (yet). (And without a rhyming dictionary, too!)EC
  10. 10The culprit was very high ....STRUNG•
  11. 11The victim was a graduate of V....MI•
  12. 12But don't let that .... your attention.AVERT•
  13. 13He wase stabbede ine the ....NECKE•
  14. 16There was a heavy .... that morning.DEW•
  15. 17A Cruel Revenge Undoubtedly.ACRU•
  16. 22The victim ....as a lady's man.POSED•
  17. 23He was .... to laugh at rural humor.QUICK•
  18. 24And had .... for all the women.II•
  19. 26He was a sheik, but not an ....ARAB•
  20. 29He extolled the .... to be found on farms. (clue).CHARMS•
  21. 30He painted pictures of goils; with words, not ....OILS•
  22. 31His humor was far from ....ARID•
  23. 35He called his customers .... seeds.HAY•
  24. 36How are you ....ing? Hay! Hay!DO•
  25. 37No one knows, how much the victim ....OWES•
  26. 38By his clothes, he was a ....ty gnumber.GNAT•
  27. 40.... doing all the work and you'll have all the fun.IM•
  28. 41Have you collected all the ....?CLUES•
  29. 43Notice How Dey're Scattered?NHDS
  30. 46Unscatter them right and your .... ended.LABOURS•
  31. 48The suspect's .... is a soil toiler. (clue).PA•
  32. 51And has a .... on his nose. (no clue).WEN•
  33. 52United Travelingmen's Laughter Association. (The victim was a member).UTLA
  34. 54He enjoyed a good .... while in the smoking car. (clue).CIGAR•
  35. 55Risque Tales (also). (clue).RT
  36. 56The culprit's .... was a bean boiler.MA•
  37. 60The victim carried her pa's .... for a gallon of red paint. (clue).IOU•
  38. 62The neighbors considered her eccentric because she ate with her ....FORK•
  39. 63All Men Tell.AMT
  40. 64When a cad is in ....; the world is his pal, but (cont.)LUV•
  41. 65When he decides to shuv; he tells on the ....GAL•
  42. 66There was no limit to the victim's jokes, when he rode the .... (abbr).LTD•
  43. 68It all took place on this continent.NA
  44. 69Early in February.FE
  45. 70And ended the romance.CE
  46. 71Effectual Hunting (with)EH
  47. 72Right Reasoning (will)RR
  48. 73Reward Everyone (with the culprit's well known monniker).RE
Where each clue was read (boxes recorded by the OCR)
Where each clue was read (boxes recorded by the OCR)

Notes

Printed with puzzle: Note: Each letter placed in the circles is a clue. The solution has three words of 3, 7, and 8 letters respectively. If you arrange your clues in the proper order, you will discover the culprit's identity.

How it was checked

  1. Found. The puzzle was located in the Internet Archive's scan of Judge (page); its answer key in a later issue.
  2. Read by OCR. The project's OCR found the grid, read 86 clues and the printed answer key, and recorded where on the page each clue sits (point at a clue below to see it).
  3. Checked by AI. Claude Fable 5.1 confirmed 11 readings against the scan, corrected 83 and checked the whole puzzle and marked it right.
    • 14 Across The No. 1 vertical got her job through an → The No. 1 vertical got her job through an .... (abbr.).
    • 15 Across In this mystery, you are → In this mystery, you are .... ....
    • 20 Across The wounds. (clue). → The .... said there were three stab wounds. (clue).
    • 21 Across The victim wore a .... pair of pants. → The victim wore a .... suit, with one pair of pants.
    • 23 Across Whoeyer did it may have suffered from a mental → Whoever did it may have suffered from a mental ....
    • 28 Across If you → If you .... the clues properly; you'll get the solution, maybe.
    • 29 Across The victim was noted for his manly → The victim was noted for his manly ....
    • 32 Across There was a bottle with a big → There was a bottle with a big .... gone from it.
    • 34 Across nzo.you still on the job? → .... you still on the job?
    • 35 Across liked to tell naughty stories. → .... liked to tell naughty stories.
    • 36 Across The victim was a gay → The victim was a gay ....
    • 39 Across No. 1 vertical had a good → No. 1 vertical had a good ....
    • 41 Across But she said the victim was bad, in fact quite a → But she said the victim was bad, in fact quite a .... (Some poetry, eh?)
    • 42 Across He had no → He had no .... enemies.
    • 50 Across (nothing) → .... .... found on floor.
    • 53 Across The culprit had had to ... → The culprit had had to .... in a hurry.
    • 57 Across This isn't becoming too..... …,is it? → This isn't becoming too ...., is it?
    • 58 Across The constable did his → The constable did his ....
    • 59 Across But → But .... was none too good.
    • 60 Across This particle had nothing to do with the mu"der." → This particle had nothing to do with the murder.
    • 63 Across The culprit had attended the State college. (clue). → The culprit had attended the State .... college. (clue).
    • 66 Across A clue! The murderer's name is → A clue! The murderer's name is ....!
    • 67 Across The victim worked for a red paint → The victim worked for a red paint ....
    • 73 Across He No. 74 horizontal on the clue). → He No. 74 horizontal on the .... (clue).
    • 75 Across The maid gave a → The maid gave a .... when she found the body.
    • 1 Down The crime was discovered by the → The crime was discovered by the ....
    • 2 Down U'tterly Dumfounded (was she). → Utterly Dumfounded (was she).
    • 5 Down Exeedin decided upon as motive. ). → .... decided upon as motive.
    • 6 Down Now we're all → Now we're all ....,
    • 7 Down last, you bet; → .... last, you bet;
    • 8 Down s go andget 's go and get → ....'s go and get
    • 10 Down The culprit was very, high → The culprit was very high ....
    • 11 Down The victim was a graduate of V → The victim was a graduate of V....
    • 12 Down But don't let that adua. your attention. → But don't let that .... your attention.
    • 13 Down He wase stabbede ine the → He wase stabbede ine the ....
    • 16 Down There was a heavy. → There was a heavy .... that morning.
    • 17 Down A. Cruel Revenge Undoubtedly. → A Cruel Revenge Undoubtedly.
    • 22 Down The victim venge Undas a lady's man. → The victim ....as a lady's man.
    • 23 Down He was → He was .... to laugh at rural humor.
    • 24 Down And had → And had .... for all the women.
    • and 43 more
  4. Checked by a person. The project's maintainer corrected 2 and checked the whole puzzle and marked it right.
    • Text printed with the puzzle NotE: Each letter placed in the circles is a clue. The solution has three words of 3, 7, and 8 letters respectively. If you arrange your clues in the proper order, you will discover the culprit's identity. → Note: Each letter placed in the circles is a clue. The solution has three words of 3, 7, and 8 letters respectively. If you arrange your clues in the proper order, you will discover the culprit's identity. (review site)
    • 4 Down Exceedingly Handsome (had been ne). → Exceedingly Handsome (had been he). (notes page)
  5. Hand fixes. 1 value was set by a recorded fix in the publication's fix file: Puzzle number.
  6. Done. The transcription matches the printed puzzle, misprints in the clues kept as printed.

Elsewhere