Every Puzzle ProjectJudge
Judge · No. 4 · November 22, 1924

Judge's Crossword Puzzle No. 4

by Alfred M. Pelham

The black squares include cross-hatched ones that spell HA HA in two corners (clue 37 Across); the solid ones spell JUDGE. The puzzle has one-letter entries (20 Across = K, 80 Across = I) in the holes of the letters; the clue numbering follows the printed puzzle, not standard numbering rules. The solution ran under No. 5 in the 29 November 1924 issue ("Answer to Puzzle No. 4"), on the one puzzle page that issue's archive.org scan has.

As printed

The puzzle as printed in Judge, November 22, 1924
The puzzle as printed in Judge, November 22, 1924 · this page at the Internet Archive
Its clues, printed on another page
Its clues, printed on another page · this page at the Internet Archive
The printed answer key
The answer key, printed in a later issue · that page at the Internet Archive

As transcribed

The grid and clues exactly as printed, misprints and all. Point at a clue to see where it was read on the page. • the OCR misread it and a reviewer fixed the reading (point at the dot for what it read); sic a misprint, kept as printed.

Across

  1. 1What his employer gave him when he asked for a raise.GATE
  2. 5A household fixture that has made Saturday night famous.BATHTUB
  3. 10About the smallest thing there is—even smaller than some Congressmen.ATOM•
  4. 15The highest point.APEX•
  5. 16A division of the United Provinces (British India)—10,159 sq. miles.AGRA•
  6. 17What you do during an after-dinner speech.YAWN•
  7. 20Three letters like this one and Rastus leaves town.K•
  8. 21The time of the year when you kid yourself by swearing off the things you don't like to do anyway:LENT•
  9. 22No two sardines could get this way.NEARER•
  10. 24This one's pronounced the same as an insect that makes honey.BE•
  11. 25Another place besides a Klan meeting where you'll find sheets.BED•
  12. 27This one often keeps company with "either."OR•
  13. 28A State close to the Mexican border. Not so old either (abr.).NM•
  14. 29Where your hat won't stay on a windy day.ON•
  15. 31A joint made by heating and hammering (not a restaurant).WELD•
  16. 34The second note that the would-be opera singer upstairs warbles just as the baby gets to sleep.RA•
  17. 35A dinky adverb meaning therefore.SO
  18. 36Used to be an appetizer, but to-day they are guzzled all the time.COCKTAIL
  19. 37This is the design worked in the lower left-hand and the upper right-hand corner of the puzzle.HA•
  20. 39A Southern State that makes a lot of noise about its peaches (abr.).GA
  21. 40Don't be selfish, No. 29 Horizontal told you all about this one.ON
  22. 41It's a good thing to know how to act in one—like when the wife comes in and finds the stenog. on your lap.EMERGENCY•
  23. 46A lubricant for wheatcakes.SYRUP•
  24. 48A possessive pronoun.MY•
  25. 49What you'd like to do about the "Follies."GO•
  26. 51Harangue.TIRADE•
  27. 53A fever attended by chills and shaking.AGUE•
  28. 54A highway (abr.).ST•
  29. 55What the cannibal did to the missionary.ATE•
  30. 56That chum of eithers again.OR•
  31. 57The first two of three letters often written on little slips of paper after a poker game has been on a few hours.IO
  32. 58What you get besides pepper when you say "please pass the pepper."SALT
  33. 60The kind of a crossing where motorists come to their own conclusions (abr.).RR
  34. 61A metal—(have you had yours to-day?)IRON
  35. 63When you can't cure a thing, you have to do this.ENDURE•
  36. 67Every X-word puzzle has to have this one somewhere—"to exist."BE•
  37. 68Most anyone knows enough Spanish to say yes.SI
  38. 70These boys have the cold dope on the future.SEERS•
  39. 72This is a pair of trousers without the "s" on the end. It's pretty hard so we'll tell you that the first four letters spell what a dog does when he is hot.PANTALOON•
  40. 74Under a name that ma and the old man didn't give you.INCOGNITO•
  41. 76This one's a little bit high-hat, means magnificent.PALATIAL•
  42. 80The most important person in the world.I•
  43. 81The kind of drink you go to Montreal for (pl.).ALES•
  44. 82The repetition of a letter which is the way an Englishman pronounces the place where a lot of us are going when we die.LL•
  45. 83What Dad calls himself when he has a junior (abr.).SR•
  46. 84Young bears.CUBS•
  47. 86What some people have nerve enough to call a Ford.CAR•
  48. 87A little word that air castles are built on.IF•
  49. 89One of those poetic personal pronouns.YE•
  50. 90An abbreviation for a disease—that people go to Denver to cure.TB•
  51. 91You've met people who think this is what they are.IT•
  52. 94A Western State where some of the men still believe that Solomon showed good judgment.UTAH•
  53. 96It's hard to write this one because it means spoken.ORAL•
  54. 98To put on the feed-bag.DINE•
  55. 99A liquid food that some people inhale.SOUP•
  56. 100This last one's Ritzy too. It's what your words do from your mouth.EMANATE•

Down

  1. 1The article of apparel that made people call young ladies flappers.GALOSH
  2. 2Something we descend from, theoretically at least.APE
  3. 3A kind of a voice not so good when described as "whisky."TENOR•
  4. 4The edition of a paper that tells all about a thing as soon as it happens.EXTRA
  5. 5We all slip on one of these sooner or later.BANANAPEEL
  6. 6What comes before beauty.AGE
  7. 7Over some doors.TRANSOM
  8. 8What any four drunks think they are capable of when they sing about "Sweet Adeline."HARMONY•
  9. 9Pronounced the same as buy.BY
  10. 10Just one.AN
  11. 11One of those pests who is always minding your business.MEDDLER
  12. 12Twice nothing.OO
  13. 13When "a young man's fancy lightly turns to thought of love."SPRING•
  14. 14One who betrays.BETRAYER
  15. 18A degree that students work (?) four years for—(not the third).AB•
  16. 19You and I.WE•
  17. 23Supposedly the richest man in the world (gives away nickels and everything).ROCKEFELLER•
  18. 25How most girls think they dance.BEAUTIFULLY•
  19. 26A pet name for the brain factory at New Haven.ELI•
  20. 30What ninety-nine out of a hundred bosses say when asked for a raise.NO•
  21. 31Too much of this is the bane of a stout woman's existence (abr.).WT•
  22. 32The only things besides promises that Congressmen hand out freely.SEEDS•
  23. 33No well behaved telephone should do this after you get to bed.RING•
  24. 38Stars (Latin).ASTRA•
  25. 39The thing that makes cats so essential to violins.GUT•
  26. 42Your one best pal (according to the Mammy songs).MA•
  27. 43What no woman is in an argument.REASONABLE•
  28. 44What any amount of candy given to children is about ten minutes later.EATEN•
  29. 45What the Giants probably did to their luck after the last game.CURST•
  30. 47When you tear your hair and gnash your teeth, you do this.RANT•
  31. 49A sailor.GOB•
  32. 50A lot of the mines that they sell stock in don't have much of this.ORE•
  33. 52A mythical maid changed by Juno into a heifer.IO•
  34. 54The way beer was drawn from kegs in the good old days.SIPHONED
  35. 59You have to have two of these to be a good marathon runner.LEG•
  36. 62The number of times opportunity knocks.ONCE•
  37. 64What a girl says when she means yes.NO•
  38. 65The only sure way to get a thing done.DO•
  39. 66What you hate to see your mother-in-law do to her trunk when she honors (?) you with a visit.UNPACKS•
  40. 68Most of us have enough of these to insure us a through ticket to the bad place.SINS•
  41. 69Where you stay when you can't go out.IN•
  42. 71A New England State (abr.).RI•
  43. 73You may use any word starting with "A" here that you want to (we used ankles).ANKLES•
  44. 75Can be made into a stew without the use of alcohol.OYSTER•
  45. 77The Southern State where Opelika is located—if that means anything to you (abr.).ALA•
  46. 78Not in the dictionary—The initials of A. Sap.AS•
  47. 79You know me—.AL•
  48. 85The place in the basement where the black diamonds are kept.BIN•
  49. 87An abbreviation for the country that spaghetti made famous.IT•
  50. 88The fourth note in the scale that some moron named harmonic.FA•
  51. 90You do this with a shuttle—(nothing at all to do with Times Square).TAT•
  52. 92This one is a common exclamation.OH•
  53. 93One more letter like these and you have an empire that you can't see.KK•
  54. 94Great minds have been baffled by how high this one is.UP•
  55. 95A masculine pronoun.HE•
  56. 96Where your clothes should be when you are out in public.ON•
  57. 97Abbreviation for rear-admiral. Just why they call him rear is the question.RA•
Where each clue was read (boxes recorded by the OCR)
Where each clue was read (boxes recorded by the OCR)

How it was checked

  1. Found. The puzzle was located in the Internet Archive's scan of Judge (page); its answer key in a later issue.
  2. Read by OCR. The project's OCR found the grid, read 86 clues and the printed answer key, and recorded where on the page each clue sits (point at a clue below to see it).
  3. Checked by a person. The project's maintainer confirmed 5 readings against the scan, corrected 10, checked the whole puzzle and marked it right and sent it back for another look.
    • region:A10 1361,622,2064,659 → 1327,622,2069,686
    • region:D1 2144,489,2858,542 → 2115,477,2881,569
    • region:D2 2112,526,2858,629 → 2099,564,2877,635
    • 10 Across About the smallest thing there is—even → About the smallest thing there is—even smaller than some Congressmen.
    • region:A20 1357,801,2069,844 → 1315,804,2101,874
    • region:A21 1329,836,1424,875 → 1322,866,2091,972
    • region:A22 1329,860,2069,1001 → 1329,950,2087,994
    • Square at row 3, column 1 R → L
    • Square at row 3, column 18 O → D (key-squares page)
    • Text printed with the puzzle (See adjoining page for Key Chart) → (removed) (notes page)
  4. Checked by AI. Claude Opus 5.5 confirmed 14 readings against the scan, corrected 198 and sent it back for another look.
    • Square at row 1, column 13 . → #
    • Square at row 1, column 14 . → #
    • Square at row 1, column 19 . → #
    • Square at row 1, column 21 . → #
    • Square at row 1, column 23 . → #
    • Square at row 1, column 24 . → #
    • Square at row 1, column 25 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 10 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 11 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 16 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 17 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 19 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 21 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 23 . → #
    • Square at row 2, column 25 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 12 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 15 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 19 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 20 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 21 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 23 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 24 . → #
    • Square at row 3, column 25 . → #
    • Square at row 4, column 13 . → #
    • Square at row 4, column 14 . → #
    • Square at row 4, column 19 . → #
    • Square at row 4, column 21 . → #
    • Square at row 4, column 23 . → #
    • Square at row 4, column 25 . → #
    • Square at row 5, column 19 . → #
    • Square at row 5, column 21 . → #
    • Square at row 5, column 23 . → #
    • Square at row 5, column 25 . → #
    • Square at row 6, column 17 . → #
    • Square at row 7, column 1 . → #
    • Square at row 7, column 22 . → #
    • Square at row 8, column 3 . → #
    • Square at row 8, column 24 . → #
    • Square at row 9, column 5 . → #
    • Square at row 9, column 26 . → #
    • and 158 more
  5. Checked by AI. Claude corrected 3.
    • note (nothing) → The black squares include cross-hatched ones that spell HA HA in two corners (clue 37 Across); the solid ones spell JUDGE. The puzzle has one-letter entries (20 Across = K, 80 Across = I) in the holes of the letters; the clue numbering follows the printed puzzle, not standard numbering rules. Solution not available: it would have run in the 29 November 1924 issue, whose archive.org scan is incomplete. (checked the grid against the printed numbers)
    • solution_missing (nothing) → it would have run in the 29 November 1924 issue; archive.org's scan of that issue (sim_judge_1924-11-22_87) has only 24 pages (checked the scans)
    • note The black squares include cross-hatched ones that spell HA HA in two corners (clue 37 Across); the solid ones spell JUDGE. The puzzle has one-letter entries (20 Across = K, 80 Across = I) in the holes of the letters; the clue numbering follows the printed puzzle, not standard numbering rules. Solution not available: it would have run in the 29 November 1924 issue, whose archive.org scan is incomplete. → (removed) (sourcing and transcription notes go in provenance, not gxd Notes)
  6. Hand fixes. 1 value was set by a recorded fix in the publication's fix file: Title.
  7. Done. The transcription matches the printed puzzle, misprints in the clues kept as printed.

Date: printed; archive.org metadata says 1924-11-15.

Elsewhere