Judge · November 15, 1924
The Greatest Puzzle of Them All (Judge cover puzzle)
Judge's first cover crossword, printed over the cover art; clues in 'Key to Judge's Cover Puzzle' on page 32.
As printed
As transcribed
The grid and clues exactly as printed, misprints and all. Point at a clue to see where it was read on the page. • the OCR misread it and a reviewer fixed the reading (point at the dot for what it read); sic a misprint, kept as printed.
1M
2O
3L
4A
R
5P
6A
7S
8S
9E
10H
A
R
E
M
11M
12S
H
O
P
13S
14A
D
A
M
15G
A
16S
17O
B
I
T
18R
E
19O
20E
R
21T
22A
R
23C
O
E
24E
N
V
E
25L
O
P
E
26S
P
27L
X
28A
T
I
L
T
29O
30N
31T
O
32M
33A
L
E
34G
35O
36H
A
37C
A
T
L
38M
A
N
I
39N
40O
D
41P
I
42E
B
43I
T
44F
45A
46P
I
E
T
47Y
48A
S
49S
50P
51L
E
A
S
U
R
52E
S
53A
54P
55T
56A
N
N
57D
S
C
58A
B
59A
R
60A
B
61O
62D
E
63L
64A
C
E
65N
A
M
E
66S
O
67T
A
C
I
T
68P
O
L
E
S
69F
A
T
E
D
Across
- 1Something she uses when eating bonbons.MOLAR
- 5Out of date (fr).PASSE
- 10A Turkish delight.HAREM
- 12Why the dear things like Fifth avenue.SHOPS
- 14The first man who couldn't say "no."ADAM
- 15Something they step on.GAS
- 17A press notice of yourself you'll never read.OBIT
- 18A musical note.RE
- 19Over.OER
- 21The boy who has a girl in every port.TAR•
- 23If three's a crowd—what's two? (abr.)CO
- 24Something the dears wear underneath.ENVELOPES•
- 27Three score (Roman).LX•
- 28How she likes to wear her hats these days.ATILT
- 29Where she keeps her hat in church.ON•
- 31A preposition.TO•
- 33A drink—she prefers ice cream sodas.ALE•
- 35An exclamation—she uses this often.OH•
- 37What she calls any woman who disapproves.CAT
- 38She takes one for better or worse.MAN•
- 39What she says—but seldom means.NO•
- 41A dessert.PIE
- 43A pronoun—what she calls some one she doesn't like.IT•
- 44A note—musical.FA
- 46Modern girls aren't so strong for this.PIETY
- 48In like manner.AS
- 50What she likes to go in for evenings.PLEASURES•
- 54What her boy friend carries on his hip (abr.).PT•
- 56A girl's name.ANN•
- 57What you'd deserve if you disagreed with her.DSC•
- 58The first two letters of the alphabet.AB•
- 59The sheik happened to be one of these.ARAB•
- 61Did you ever sit down and write her one?ODE•
- 63Something to do with dressing—the modern girl seems to have discarded.LACE•
- 65Something they change—bless 'em!NAMES•
- 67Consent implied—but not stated outright.TACIT•
- 68The inhabitants of a nation in Europe.POLES•
- 69Destined.FATED•
Down
- 1Assured of success.MADE
- 2An Anglo-Saxon money of account (better try the horizontals).ORA
- 3This girl is not one.LEMON
- 4Very early.AM
- 6Similar to.AS
- 7Where the good-looking lifeguard takes her.SHORE
- 8What she does when she wants to get her way.SOB
- 9Heroic narrative.EPIC
- 10He has long ears (not a donkey).HARE
- 11She has lost her job as chaperone.MA
- 13What she says when you first try to kiss her.STOP
- 15What they might have named her if she were German.GRETA•
- 16What she did to the poor boy's heart.STOLE•
- 20A character in "Uncle Tom's Cabin."EVA•
- 22She gets this way early.APT•
- 24A prefix.EX
- 25Flowers of the valley.LILLIES
- 26In like manner or degree.SO•
- 27Behold!LO•
- 30What she does not say at the altar.NO
- 31If she doesn't freckle.TAN
- 32How she gets when you are a few minutes late.MAD•
- 34What they do when they meet at the Sorority.GAB•
- 36What she tries to make.HIT•
- 40A proposition.OF
- 41A musical instrument.PIANO
- 42A study—musical.ETUDE•
- 43Third person singular present indicative of a verb (didn't you ever go to school?).IS•
- 45Associated Press (this will make you think!).AP•
- 46Where those who forget to pay their alimony go.PEN•
- 47What she hates to see come around (abr.).YRS•
- 48(If you found 48 Horizontal, this will be easy.)AS•
- 49To harness together.SPAN
- 51To mark.LABEL•
- 52Striking (fr.).ECLAT•
- 53To aid.ABET•
- 55What she sets when she puckers her lips.TRAP•
- 58A hard test to stand.ACID•
- 60Love (Latin).AMO•
- 62Another way to spell dew (this is foolish).DO•
- 64They're never really safe till they're down and out.ACE•
- 66A direction (abr.).SE•
- 67She says this twice as you are leaving.TA•
Notes
Printed with puzzle:
THE GREATEST PUZZLE OF THEM ALL
How it was checked
- Found. The puzzle was located in the Internet Archive's scan of Judge (page); its answer key in a later issue.
- Read by OCR. The project's OCR found the grid, read 81 clues and the printed answer key, and recorded where on the page each clue sits (point at a clue below to see it).
- Checked by a person. The project's maintainer corrected 1 and checked the whole puzzle and marked it right.
- Text printed with the puzzle
(See Page 31 for Key Chart)→ (removed) (notes page)
- Text printed with the puzzle
- Checked by AI. Claude Opus 5.5 confirmed 15 readings against the scan, corrected 66 and sent it back for another look.
- Square at row 2, column 12
D→ P - 21 Across
The boy who has a girl in→ The boy who has a girl in every port. - 22 Across
every port.→ (removed) - 24 Across
(nothing)→ Something the dears wear underneath. - 25 Across
Something the dears wear underneath.→ (removed) - 26 Across
Three score (Roman).→ (removed) - 27 Across
(nothing)→ Three score (Roman). - 29 Across
(nothing)→ Where she keeps her hat in church. - 30 Across
Where she keeps her hat in church.→ (removed) - 31 Across
(nothing)→ A preposition. - 32 Across
A preposition.→ (removed) - 33 Across
(nothing)→ A drink—she prefers ice cream sodas. - 34 Across
A drink—she prefers ice cream sodas.→ (removed) - 35 Across
(nothing)→ An exclamation—she uses this often. - 36 Across
An exclamation—she uses this often.→ (removed) - 38 Across
She takes one for better or worse. 39. What she says—but seldom means.→ She takes one for better or worse. - 39 Across
(nothing)→ What she says—but seldom means. - 42 Across
A pronoun—what she calls some one she doesn't like.→ (removed) - 43 Across
(nothing)→ A pronoun—what she calls some one she doesn't like. - 50 Across
(nothing)→ What she likes to go in for evenings. - 51 Across
What she likes to go in for evenings.→ (removed) - 53 Across
What her boy friend carries on his hip (abr.).→ (removed) - 54 Across
A girl's name.→ What her boy friend carries on his hip (abr.). - 56 Across
What you'd deserve if you disagreed with her. 58. The first two letters of the alphabet.→ A girl's name. - 57 Across
The sheik happened to be one of these. 61. Did you ever sit down and write her one?→ What you'd deserve if you disagreed with her. - 58 Across
Something to do with dressing -the modern girl seems to have discarded. 65. Something they change—bless 'em!→ The first two letters of the alphabet. - 59 Across
Consent implied—but not stated outright. 68. The inhabitants of a nation in Europe. 69. Destined.→ The sheik happened to be one of these. - 61 Across
(nothing)→ Did you ever sit down and write her one? - 63 Across
(nothing)→ Something to do with dressing—the modern girl seems to have discarded. - 65 Across
(nothing)→ Something they change—bless 'em! - 67 Across
(nothing)→ Consent implied—but not stated outright. - 68 Across
(nothing)→ The inhabitants of a nation in Europe. - 69 Across
(nothing)→ Destined. - 15 Down
(nothing)→ What they might have named her if she were German. - 16 Down
What they might have named her if she were German.→ What she did to the poor boy's heart. - 20 Down
What she did to the poor boy's heart.→ A character in "Uncle Tom's Cabin." - 22 Down
A character in "Uncle Tom's Cabin."→ She gets this way early. - 23 Down
She gets this way early.→ (removed) - 26 Down
(nothing)→ In like manner or degree. - 27 Down
In like manner or degree.→ Behold! - and 26 more
- Square at row 2, column 12
- Hand fixes. 1 value was set by a recorded fix in the publication's fix file: Title.
- Done. The transcription matches the printed puzzle, misprints in the clues kept as printed.
Date: printed; archive.org metadata says 1924-11-08.
Elsewhere
- This puzzle on The Cross Reference: its answers and clues among every other crossword
- judge1924-11-15.xd, the transcription as a file
- The review page, where every reading sits beside its crop of the scan
- The OCR packet (what the OCR read, as data)

