Every Puzzle ProjectJudge
Judge · November 15, 1924

The Greatest Puzzle of Them All (Judge cover puzzle)

Judge's first cover crossword, printed over the cover art; clues in 'Key to Judge's Cover Puzzle' on page 32.

As printed

The puzzle as printed in Judge, November 15, 1924
The puzzle as printed in Judge, November 15, 1924 · this page at the Internet Archive
Its clues, printed on another page
Its clues, printed on another page · this page at the Internet Archive

As transcribed

The grid and clues exactly as printed, misprints and all. Point at a clue to see where it was read on the page. • the OCR misread it and a reviewer fixed the reading (point at the dot for what it read); sic a misprint, kept as printed.

Across

  1. 1Something she uses when eating bonbons.MOLAR
  2. 5Out of date (fr).PASSE
  3. 10A Turkish delight.HAREM
  4. 12Why the dear things like Fifth avenue.SHOPS
  5. 14The first man who couldn't say "no."ADAM
  6. 15Something they step on.GAS
  7. 17A press notice of yourself you'll never read.OBIT
  8. 18A musical note.RE
  9. 19Over.OER
  10. 21The boy who has a girl in every port.TAR•
  11. 23If three's a crowd—what's two? (abr.)CO
  12. 24Something the dears wear underneath.ENVELOPES•
  13. 27Three score (Roman).LX•
  14. 28How she likes to wear her hats these days.ATILT
  15. 29Where she keeps her hat in church.ON•
  16. 31A preposition.TO•
  17. 33A drink—she prefers ice cream sodas.ALE•
  18. 35An exclamation—she uses this often.OH•
  19. 37What she calls any woman who disapproves.CAT
  20. 38She takes one for better or worse.MAN•
  21. 39What she says—but seldom means.NO•
  22. 41A dessert.PIE
  23. 43A pronoun—what she calls some one she doesn't like.IT•
  24. 44A note—musical.FA
  25. 46Modern girls aren't so strong for this.PIETY
  26. 48In like manner.AS
  27. 50What she likes to go in for evenings.PLEASURES•
  28. 54What her boy friend carries on his hip (abr.).PT•
  29. 56A girl's name.ANN•
  30. 57What you'd deserve if you disagreed with her.DSC•
  31. 58The first two letters of the alphabet.AB•
  32. 59The sheik happened to be one of these.ARAB•
  33. 61Did you ever sit down and write her one?ODE•
  34. 63Something to do with dressing—the modern girl seems to have discarded.LACE•
  35. 65Something they change—bless 'em!NAMES•
  36. 67Consent implied—but not stated outright.TACIT•
  37. 68The inhabitants of a nation in Europe.POLES•
  38. 69Destined.FATED•

Down

  1. 1Assured of success.MADE
  2. 2An Anglo-Saxon money of account (better try the horizontals).ORA
  3. 3This girl is not one.LEMON
  4. 4Very early.AM
  5. 6Similar to.AS
  6. 7Where the good-looking lifeguard takes her.SHORE
  7. 8What she does when she wants to get her way.SOB
  8. 9Heroic narrative.EPIC
  9. 10He has long ears (not a donkey).HARE
  10. 11She has lost her job as chaperone.MA
  11. 13What she says when you first try to kiss her.STOP
  12. 15What they might have named her if she were German.GRETA•
  13. 16What she did to the poor boy's heart.STOLE•
  14. 20A character in "Uncle Tom's Cabin."EVA•
  15. 22She gets this way early.APT•
  16. 24A prefix.EX
  17. 25Flowers of the valley.LILLIES
  18. 26In like manner or degree.SO•
  19. 27Behold!LO•
  20. 30What she does not say at the altar.NO
  21. 31If she doesn't freckle.TAN
  22. 32How she gets when you are a few minutes late.MAD•
  23. 34What they do when they meet at the Sorority.GAB•
  24. 36What she tries to make.HIT•
  25. 40A proposition.OF
  26. 41A musical instrument.PIANO
  27. 42A study—musical.ETUDE•
  28. 43Third person singular present indicative of a verb (didn't you ever go to school?).IS•
  29. 45Associated Press (this will make you think!).AP•
  30. 46Where those who forget to pay their alimony go.PEN•
  31. 47What she hates to see come around (abr.).YRS•
  32. 48(If you found 48 Horizontal, this will be easy.)AS•
  33. 49To harness together.SPAN
  34. 51To mark.LABEL•
  35. 52Striking (fr.).ECLAT•
  36. 53To aid.ABET•
  37. 55What she sets when she puckers her lips.TRAP•
  38. 58A hard test to stand.ACID•
  39. 60Love (Latin).AMO•
  40. 62Another way to spell dew (this is foolish).DO•
  41. 64They're never really safe till they're down and out.ACE•
  42. 66A direction (abr.).SE•
  43. 67She says this twice as you are leaving.TA•
Where each clue was read (boxes recorded by the OCR)
Where each clue was read (boxes recorded by the OCR)

Notes

Printed with puzzle: THE GREATEST PUZZLE OF THEM ALL

How it was checked

  1. Found. The puzzle was located in the Internet Archive's scan of Judge (page); its answer key in a later issue.
  2. Read by OCR. The project's OCR found the grid, read 81 clues and the printed answer key, and recorded where on the page each clue sits (point at a clue below to see it).
  3. Checked by a person. The project's maintainer corrected 1 and checked the whole puzzle and marked it right.
    • Text printed with the puzzle (See Page 31 for Key Chart) → (removed) (notes page)
  4. Checked by AI. Claude Opus 5.5 confirmed 15 readings against the scan, corrected 66 and sent it back for another look.
    • Square at row 2, column 12 D → P
    • 21 Across The boy who has a girl in → The boy who has a girl in every port.
    • 22 Across every port. → (removed)
    • 24 Across (nothing) → Something the dears wear underneath.
    • 25 Across Something the dears wear underneath. → (removed)
    • 26 Across Three score (Roman). → (removed)
    • 27 Across (nothing) → Three score (Roman).
    • 29 Across (nothing) → Where she keeps her hat in church.
    • 30 Across Where she keeps her hat in church. → (removed)
    • 31 Across (nothing) → A preposition.
    • 32 Across A preposition. → (removed)
    • 33 Across (nothing) → A drink—she prefers ice cream sodas.
    • 34 Across A drink—she prefers ice cream sodas. → (removed)
    • 35 Across (nothing) → An exclamation—she uses this often.
    • 36 Across An exclamation—she uses this often. → (removed)
    • 38 Across She takes one for better or worse. 39. What she says—but seldom means. → She takes one for better or worse.
    • 39 Across (nothing) → What she says—but seldom means.
    • 42 Across A pronoun—what she calls some one she doesn't like. → (removed)
    • 43 Across (nothing) → A pronoun—what she calls some one she doesn't like.
    • 50 Across (nothing) → What she likes to go in for evenings.
    • 51 Across What she likes to go in for evenings. → (removed)
    • 53 Across What her boy friend carries on his hip (abr.). → (removed)
    • 54 Across A girl's name. → What her boy friend carries on his hip (abr.).
    • 56 Across What you'd deserve if you disagreed with her. 58. The first two letters of the alphabet. → A girl's name.
    • 57 Across The sheik happened to be one of these. 61. Did you ever sit down and write her one? → What you'd deserve if you disagreed with her.
    • 58 Across Something to do with dressing -the modern girl seems to have discarded. 65. Something they change—bless 'em! → The first two letters of the alphabet.
    • 59 Across Consent implied—but not stated outright. 68. The inhabitants of a nation in Europe. 69. Destined. → The sheik happened to be one of these.
    • 61 Across (nothing) → Did you ever sit down and write her one?
    • 63 Across (nothing) → Something to do with dressing—the modern girl seems to have discarded.
    • 65 Across (nothing) → Something they change—bless 'em!
    • 67 Across (nothing) → Consent implied—but not stated outright.
    • 68 Across (nothing) → The inhabitants of a nation in Europe.
    • 69 Across (nothing) → Destined.
    • 15 Down (nothing) → What they might have named her if she were German.
    • 16 Down What they might have named her if she were German. → What she did to the poor boy's heart.
    • 20 Down What she did to the poor boy's heart. → A character in "Uncle Tom's Cabin."
    • 22 Down A character in "Uncle Tom's Cabin." → She gets this way early.
    • 23 Down She gets this way early. → (removed)
    • 26 Down (nothing) → In like manner or degree.
    • 27 Down In like manner or degree. → Behold!
    • and 26 more
  5. Hand fixes. 1 value was set by a recorded fix in the publication's fix file: Title.
  6. Done. The transcription matches the printed puzzle, misprints in the clues kept as printed.

Date: printed; archive.org metadata says 1924-11-08.

Elsewhere